I appreciate that EVGA is trying to improve the experience for its customers, but it would be nice to know a few more details before we all give our preferences...
For those who already purchased a card, but not necessarily the one they wanted, would they be kicked from the remaining queues and have no hope of getting the card they really wanted? I'm sure a lot of folks signed up and purchased a 3060 when they really wanted, for example, a 3080.
How about the SKUs that catch up (I hope some of them eventually do)? Are they going to go to first come, first served? IE, bots get them all? I'd like to have EVGA let us know what they would do for this situation. If we switch to #2, some queues might actually catch up. Like now! Would hate to see bots/scalpers get all of the new ones that are produced instead of folks currently on the list who want more than one card and have no intention of scalping it.
Any time a scalper gets a card, the situation gets incrementally worse for everyone. In an ideal world, I'd love to see anyone on the list who hasn't gotten a single 30 series card be able to "jump the line." The rest of the people can stay in line and when everyone in line has gotten at least one card, begin to serve the other people who have already gotten one or more 30 series card. That fights bots/scalpers and allows people who really want/need more than one GPU to still be able to have a fair method to get one at MSRP. Downside is that I know people will find ways to work around this. Now, cheaters have a way to jump the line. It's not like EVGA will ask for my social security number to prove I never got a card before. And, well, that is another reason to not do #2. People will just find ways to make another account and use another CC and ship to another address. I'm sure some do it already. #2 gives them more reason to do it.
I hope others in this community do have some good ideas for improvements, but I hate to say it... I think what EVGA is doing now is about as good as it gets. If people have ideas on ensuring each person really only gets one card, the process can be improved. But until that happens, I can't envision many improvements and I'm afraid #2 will actually make the situation worse for many.