Great First Post
p2andrew for 2017.
Did you read Post #7 above?
"Long story short = A PSU will supply only what it's asked to supply, up to a point, by the hardware, even faulty hardware..Almost certainly not the fault of the PSU."
Maybe you should have created your own Thread as you do have a different PSU an unknown Graphics Cards an unknown Motherboard.
The EVGA GQ 850 Gold PSU and the P2 1000w PSU are not the Same Power Supplies.
Any Photos to show the damage you are writing about?