Just made an account to post here. Digikey has all those pad sizes and more.
Laird Technologies makes some graphite pads that sound similar to what you described with the OG pads. A bit pricey though.
A18330-09 is the manufacturer product number for the 2.25mm on the digikey website (digikey PN 926-A18330-09-ND)
The datasheet on Laird's site looks promising too.