I don’t know that answer. Nothing I’ve said about this capacitor issue precludes other issues on any manufacture’s boards, even EVGA’s. It could also be that the capacitor thing is only a band aid and that a true and proper fix requires a more involved change that manufacturers simply choose to treat as a defect.
I speak from experience. Sometimes you can make changes that totally resolve an issue and sometimes it’s a more fundamental problem.
Thing is, since EVGA says all their retail cards are proper, any other manufacturer’s cards failing clocks due to the capacitor issue is irrelevant. EVGA cards failing clocks would likely be some other issue. I can’t say for certain and am just taking them at their word. But EVGA guarantees these cards will hit and hold advertised clocks.
As these IC features get smaller, voltages get more critical. There is less margin for increasing or decreasing voltage. The 4 bit bits used on the memory bus are even more critical on voltages as they slice the logic voltage into 4 sublevels. We are probably going to have to rely more on the silicon lottery in the future than on our own ability to tweak voltages to get the highest clocks.
And users reporting issues only hints there could be a problem. It doesn’t mean there is one. So many are trying to run 3000 series cards on below-recommended rating power supplies and/or putting Y adapters on a single video power cable it’s not funny. The closer you get to a power supply's maximum rating, the more ripple and noise will be on the bus for mobo and video. That noise contributes big time to system overclockability or lack thereof. Until we see anecdotal evidence of crashing that excludes power and other issues, it’s hard to trust it.
What I do know is EVGA stands behind their stuff. I got a free step up over the thermal pad issue on the 10 series, and even a great deal on an EVGA power supply thrown in as a bonus. If you get an EVGA card that can’t hit its advertised clocks, they will make it right.
Actually, with how I was treated over that thermal pad issue, I’d be happy to get a slightly gimpy 3090 FTW3 Ultra because I know I’d at least get a great one in return and who knows what else. But I doubt that will happen.
On the other hand, I want a 3090 FTW3 Ultra. I need to stop posting so the rumor mill can give me the chance to get an order completed. 😁