Eurodancer
That's exactly why I've been on the fence. I have been thinking "well, If I adjust my fan speed, then I might be okay" or similar to what you said "it probably won't happen to me since the number reported have been so few." I've been going back and forth with this, but it will ALWAYS be I the back of my head if I keep it. I've also been thinking "heck, even if I go with another brand, there will still be some sort of issue." Haha right now I feel almost a lose lose, but I'm trying to think of the path of least resistance - what will be a better choice right now, and a choice that will not make me have anxiety about possibly overheating and damaging other components, even if it's not a large % of cards. Just knowing mine was shipped on 8/03/16 to my retailer makes me uneasy. I guess in the end, it's all psychological. Funny how that works...
I understand it perfectly where you're coming from. And honestly, I share your uneasiness.
Even though everything points to the cards working fine even with the 0db preset, you automatically feel you should make a custom preset or select the aggressive preset just to keep them cooler, after seeing those tests.
Even though they work fine in theory it just feels like you have to tweak whatever to have peace of mind.
Eurodancer
One more thing. Let me ask you. If you were in my situation, would you return to retailer, and then wait for thr new batch of cards pre-installed with thermal pads? I'm debating this or just returning and getting a new brand. I really really want to like this model. Mind you, I am not over clocking the gpu.
If you have the option to return it, I would if I were you.
Then I'd probably buy EVGA again just because I know the support is good. I've had ASUS cards and their support was beyond bad.
Gigabyte is good quality but their support isn't so good, too.
Can't tell you anything about MSI's support, but at least from a MOBO point of a view they build great products. And their cards seem to be on par.
Gainward and Palit make pretty good cards too, but no idea how their support is.
So yeah, I guess it's just a matter of preference. If you don't want to buy EVGA again just go with the one who has a better cooling solution. That's what I would do.
But hey, at the end of the day, fact of the matter is our cards are working fine, and even some people who have overclocked them have them running without hiccups.
I'll install the pads just for peace of mind, because from what I've seen and from my usage I'll probably never have any issues with my card, knock on wood.