I did return both my original to Amazon and the RMA back to EVGA. I happened to be browsing nowinstock and noticed that Amazon had the GB GTX 1080 Extreme Premium Pack in stock so I added one to my cart and was actually able to checkout before they went out of stock (right after I finished the purchase they went to zero stock).
I received the card today and it is currently undergoing burn-in and testing, but I would like to post some information purely for others that might be interested.
* The card is massive. And I mean HUGE. I didn't measure it before installing but it takes up 3 full slots and seems to be quite a bit longer than the FTW.
* The build quality is far inferior to the EVGA - the card feels flimsy and cheap, and the rear fins were bent just like others had complained. The breakout box is flimsy and cheap, feels like a $5 item from the grab bin at MicroCenter. However the the front panel is very convenient to have for my VIVE and the extra USB 3.0 ports are a nice bonus.
* I noticed the actual retail box was NOT sealed, but everything inside was and the card itself was in a sealed package. The box is huge compared to the FTW.
* The back-plate is a nice feature but no where near as good as the EVGA - about half the thickness from just eyeballing it.
* The card runs hot - approx. 10c more than my FTW even with cooler room temperatures - however I do need to improve the cooling in my case and that should help quite a bit. With the FTW you won't need to worry about that.
* I won the silicon lottery this time - my card is able to boost to 2100Mhz *easily* and the RAM is at 10,206Mhz. I have not even messed with the voltages yet, and probably won't at this point.
* No coil whine. Yet. EDIT: Yes there is, noticeably louder than the FTW. Does not bother me because I use headphones, but others should be aware.
* SLI Bridge is nice considering the price they are going for.
So this card doesn't come close to the build quality of the FTW - if you are able to secure a NEW working FTW I would stick with it. I am very pleased with my purchase though *so far*, but only time will tell I know from previous experience that GB quality can be questionable.