scoakley
I'm not sure, but given that my 1080 FTW has gone from idling at 40 C to idling at 60 C (and hitting 92 C under load) over the course of two days, I would be prepared to replace the paste.
WOW - are your GPU fans spinning? I ask because that is way too hot.
As to the OP, I'm not certain which paste is used - I also replace their paste with ICDiamond just because they tend to have too much paste applied.
The nice thing is that with EVGA replacing the paste doesn't void the warranty - as long as you don't short out anything by using electrically conductive TIM.