tripstyle
Forum lurker checking in..
Thanks Eduncan911, your posting has totally inspired me. I was initially considering this back in september but was hesitant due to the nvidia performance issues. Now with the 2013-12-18 release of cudaminer my interest has finally peaked and I've decided to take the jump. I rarely use my gaming rig these days. It's just gathering dust for the most part and i feel there's no better time to get the ball rolling. Plus it gives me a nice little incentive to maintain the rig.
First, be sure to read over my Titans mining thread here:
http://forums.evga.com/tm.aspx?m=2089066 Specifically, the two posts where I figured out a "Temp Target" undervolting trick on the 700 series. You will want to do that.
http://forums.evga.com/tm.aspx?m=2089066#2089744 (and the next post after that)
tripstyle
Questions:
- Looking at these results, the 780ti isn't far behind the R9 290. However, what are the differences in terms of power consumption? (even a vague % figure would be most helpful).
Very poor. All Nvidia GPUs have a low khash-to-watt ratio. I've managed to squeeze around 1.4 khash per watt out of my Titans using a custom BIOS, temp target max undervolting, and wishful thinking. It's not an official number yet as I don't have my watt meters yet. But, it's close per my UPS' amperage reading (it's an APC 2200W 20 Amp server UPS with a remote management card).
In contrast, the 7970, R9 280x, R9 290 and R9 290x all have well over a 2:1 ratio. The 290x being the best.
Yes, you can get double the hashes, for half the wattage. or going all Nvidia, you'll only get 1/2 the khash for each watt that you could with ATI cards.
It does add up, but not a whole lot. My power usage from two Titans maxed to the sky is estimated to be about $2.75/day. So, 3x 7970s would be about $1.40/day at about the same 1,450 khash/s. At that khash, you can make about $25 to $30/day. So what's an extra $1.30 loss per day? You'd loose more in exchange rates playing the market! LOL
tripstyle
- What kind of Khash/s can i expect with my vanilla 780 in comparison to the ti with this setup?
Look into my Titan thread I first linked to above. Several have posted their 780 and 780 Ti hashes in it. I think it's around 500 to 520 if you don't touch it, and you can squeeze 600-ish with overclocking and undervolting with the Temp Target trick to keep it down from the Power Target limiter.
I went back to stock BIOS on the Titans and it was a PITA at the low power target limits of 106%. So I went back to custom BIOS. I highly recommend flashing a custom BIOS for any of these 600 and 700 GPUs with the Power Target limits - you'll hit a wall every time (and it's a steep wall, as it downclocks BIG time!).
tripstyle
- I'm expecting to go SLI once i get started. What would be the most economic route to go down out of the following three: 1. Buy another vanilla 780 on ebay 2. Sell the 780 on ebay and search around for a good deal on a pair of ti's. (seeing as they are newer i'm guessing there are much better deals to be had on 780s, but is it worth the performance drop for the price difference)? 3. Sell the 780 on ebay and buy 2x R9 290's and unlock them. I'm pretty set in my ways with nvidia (driver quality, physx etc). However, it is tempting if the price/performance and difference in energy consumption is considerable. Cudaminer has caught up recently, so i'm hoping it will go further to decrease the gap however.
SLI just for gaming, right? No sweet! :) Doesn't mean jack diddy **** in mining.
(this is off topic) Most economic route is to go with a 2nd 780 as the Ti isn't that much faster. If you only have a single monitor, I am not even sure a 2nd 780 is worth it. My single 780 Classified max out BF3 at 65 to 80 FPS @ 1920x1080p @ 60 hz. But then again, I have 120 Hz monitors, and I have 3 for Nvidia Surround gaming at 6000x1080. So, uh, I need more horse power! Just don't go 3-way (except with blondes) - I had series micro-stutter and input lag issues with 3 different 3-way setups, until I sold one of my 670s and was forced to play with 2-way. Oh man! FPS was lower, sure, but no more stutter! no more input lag! It was buttery smooth!
Now, that was for gaming... If you plan on mining with these GPUs, oh hell yeah sell that sucker! use the funds for a single R9 290 (MSRP: $399) or R9 290x (MSRP: $550) if you can find one. I put the MSRP there so you can see how much of a price gouging that is going on. I got my GPUs from Taiwan before the New Year's price increases. I can put yo in touch with him if you like, but the prices have increased significantly that you might find a better deal in the states (plus, he now charges $75/shipping).
Personally, I do plan on throwing in two of the R9 280x I just bought to do some gaming to tinker with. Kind of hard to do that when they are making $20/day you know. LOL
I plan on keeping my Titans, even though I could sale them for a nice profit for what I paid for and buy a whole lot of mining stuff with. I am keeping them because of the 6 GB ram (even though only 384bit bus limits its usage) and generally tingling feeling I get on the inside when I see them. I've learned so much about them with the custom BIOS and know its limits. Only maybe when something comes out that beats it at twice the performance may I consider upgrading - but that will be a while. My rig (see sig) does BF4 @ 6000x1080 @ 120 hz at a solid 80 FPS with everything maxed. I usually lower the MSAA a tad though to get it to 100+ FPS. So I'm happy for a while.